Gold Creek

The Site of Montana’s First Gold Strike – the Areas Best Kept Secret | Gold Creek, Montana: A Community Profile

by Ruth Little with Rick and Susie Graetz
Camp Mak-A-Dream
Camp Mak-A-Dream in Gold Creek | Courtesy of Camp Mak-A-Dream

Sixty miles east of Missoula on Interstate 90, at milepost 166, a highway marker shows an exit for Gold Creek. In the absence of signs designating this as a significant spot in Montana’s chronicles, motorists zip by at 80mph without a thought of stopping.

A southerly glance shows the peaceful ranch lands of the Clark Fork River Valley gradually ascending upward toward the Flint Creek Range’s peaks. And just a bit east of the road into this small community of about 200 people, the town’s namesake, Gold Creek, gives up its waters to the Clark Fork River.

But far more than pleasing scenery, there is the essence of place, which makes this location a perfect mix of time and space. What happened here in a more boisterous era is what defines it and belies its stillness today.

Numerous accounts abound about Montana’s first gold strike. The most credible is that a trapper named Francois Finlay (also known as “Benetsee”) found the first gold in 1852 in what became Benetsee Creek. After doing some gold panning, Finlay preferred to keep his find a secret. So, it wasn’t until the spring of 1858 that the area saw any consequential prospecting. By early 1860, American Fork, the state’s first gold camp and the forerunner of today’s quiet hamlet, was established.

Tipi at Camp Mak-A-Dream | Courtesy of Camp Mak-A-Dream

If location is an essential asset of real estate, then the camp was sitting in the right spot. On July 1, 1859 in Walla Walla, Washington, crews commenced work on the 624-mile-long Mullan Road.  Originally meant as a military passage across the Rocky Mountains connecting the Inland of the Pacific Northwest with the head of steamboat navigation on the Missouri River at Fort Benton, Montana, however, within months of its completion in 1861, miners and travelers started using it.  In July 1860, the arduous endeavor reached American Fork, which was then guaranteed a steady delivery of customers, workers, and supplies.  

The success of the Mullan Road affected congress’s decision to back the railroad construction of the 1880s. Therefore, on September 8, 1883, with much fanfare and within eye-sight of Gold Creek, the transcontinental Northern Pacific Railway’s last spike was driven. In recounting the celebration, the Flathead Courier wrote, “One of Most Distinguished Crowds Ever Assembled in the West Was in Attendance at the Driving of the Golden Spike at Gold Creek Station; President U.S. Grant Was Member of Party; Everyone Was Lavishly Entertained.” 

Granville Stuart, often referred to as the “Father of Montana” or “Mr. Montana” is perhaps the most important name to be associated with Gold Creek of today.

Stuart and his brother James had been prospecting in the California gold fields. In the spring of 1857, they made the decision to head back to Iowa to visit their parents. Hearing from some men who said they’d had good prospects at Benetsee Creek, the two brothers and their friend Reese Anderson, according to Stuart,

“as we had an inclination to see a little mountain life, we concluded to go out to that region, and winter and look around a little… and in the spring of 1858, we went over to Deer Lodge to prospected on ‘Benetsee creek…”

Clark Fork Valley
Clark Fork Valley—Flint Creek Range near Gold Creek | Rick and Susie Graetz

They spent the winter of 1857-1858 in Montana’s Beaverhead and Big Hole valleys and then as the spring thaw arrived, they traveled north to the Flint Creek Valley where they made camps about three miles south of today’s Philipsburg and about where Hall is now.

On May 2, they packed up their tools which consisted of an old square spade with a hand hold broken out of the top of the handle and a bread pan and started for the creek. After about ten miles, searching for evidence of prospecting and finding none, they moved on. Near the bank of the creek, at the foot of the mountains they sank a five-foot deep hole and found ten cents in fine gold to the pan of sand and gravel, which convinced them there were rich gold deposits in this area. That hole, stated Stuart, was “the first prospecting hole done in Montana and was the account of the first real discovery of gold within the state.”

Alas, as they lacked provisions and were extremely unprepared for the demanding task of mining, the trio packed up and headed to Fort Bridger, a post on the Oregon Trail in southwest Wyoming. It wasn’t until the fall of 1860 that the three returned better prepared to find fortune. On May 8, they set the first string of sluices ever used in Montana and began to mine by the old pick and shovel process along today’s Gold Creek then still called Benetsee Creek. 

Historical records are a bit fuzzy as to when the stream’s name change to Gold Creek. Sometime in 1862, locals changed the community’s name to Gold Creek, so it is assumed by then the name of the waterway was being called Gold Creek.

When Stuart returned from Wyoming, he built a cabin near where the creek and the Clark Fork meet. Eventually, word got out and other miners made their way to the drainage. He christened the new settlement American Fork and as it grew, Granville and his brother established a trading post, blacksmith shop, and a wagon and firearms repair business – presumably all in one building. Others established a hotel, and from viewing old maps, it appears the structure was on the Mullan Road. Eventually, the lodging became a welcome respite from a tough journey to people going to or coming from the steamboat landing at Fort Benton and points along the way.

Henry Plummer, who would eventually become the infamous outlaw sheriff of Bannack, stayed with the Stuarts at American Fork while Reece Anderson went to work on fixing Plummer’s double-barreled shotgun, “which had been broken off at the grip, coming through the timber from Elk City.”  Or at least that was his story. Plummer had been in prison in Elk City.

On May 14, 1862, things started getting busy, a party of prospectors came to town and found diggings that paid 20 cents per pan and May 20 saw another party of gold-seekers arrive. They searched a branch of Gold Creek which they named Pikes Peak Creek.  

Although it did experience some short-lived prosperity, American Fork never became a boomtown but remained a small outpost with the population never totaling more than 50 people. It wasn’t long before two events drew miners away: 1. Montana’s first major gold discovery on Grasshopper Creek on July 28, 1862 and by autumn Bannack came into existence. 2. The next spring, the state’s largest strikes grew into Virginia City. 

By 1862, Granville Stuart had become an on and off resident of the town he created. In November 1862, he left for the newly created mining camp of Bannack, where he opened a butcher shop. Apparently by April 1863, he sold everything there and returned to what was now being called Gold Creek. Sometime while he was away, the name of the creek was changed to its present name, Gold Creek.

As the summer of 1863 was ending, he again left Gold Creek to open a variety of businesses in Virginia City and, except for a visit in later years, never returned.

Although the town of Gold Creek was fading into history, new mining activity picked up above the original camp and folks settled just west of the town site.

Pioneer, four or so miles south of the first camp, was organized in 1866. It had its best years in the 1870s claiming several hotels, blacksmith, shops, and general stores.  At the height of the mining there were 500 people, four breweries, and six saloons. 

Chinese laborers came in the 1880s and worked the tailings. Later, the creek was dredged and today there are parts of dredges around the tailing piles as well as ruins of some of the buildings.

St. Mary's Missoun Catholic Church
St. Mary’s Mission Catholic Church near Gold Creek | Rick and Susie Graetz

Presently, Gold Creek is a quiet ranching community with descendants of some of the original settlers still in residence. As a sign on the building proudly exclaims, its post office was built in 1866. The old brick Milwaukee Railroad building—the tracks long gone—is now in use by a local contractor.

Several old barns and the schoolhouse consisting of two homestead schools joined together are still in use.  St. Mary’s Mission Catholic Church, built in 1910, is another landmark and is occasionally used for weddings and community and family gatherings. And trains of Burlington-Northern Railway that had been the Northern Pacific still whistle by.

Above town, on private property, is a monument with these words, “Here the first gold panned out of the gravels of eastern Idaho (now Montana) May 2,1858, by Granville Stuart and his party.  Erected by Mary E. Morony, May 2nd, 1916.”  And nearby is what is left of the tree that was utilized on August 22, 1862, for Montana’s first hanging; the victim was a horse rustler.

As for the camp American Fork, nothing is left except for a sign, on private property, that claims this is where Montana’s first gold camp was located.